top of page


Garth's cares about our one-on-one relationships with our clients.
Therefore, your comments, both positive and/or constructive, are important to this company.

Please connect with us and share your thoughts on what we do that you love or what we can do better!

We look forward to hearing from you. Submit your review.
Your comment will be read during normal business hours.
Read on to to see what others have said about us and our services. 

Lisa L.


Personal Touch - This is a first-class company that treats its clients with the utmost respect. It was a personal help to me in arranging the shipping, which was fast and well done. I love the piece I bought and enjoyed the auction. I follow their auctions for consistent high quality items.

Carol W.


There was an issue initially with receiving my auction item but they corrected the problem promptly. They even paid for the shipping cost to compensate me for the delay! They also called me twice, once to apologize for the delay and then again to make sure I got the shipment. They are family owned and really care about their customers!  Thanks, Garth's Auctions!

Sara S.


My family and I have sold many pieces with Garth's Auctions.  Mr. Jeffers and his professional staff have been very courteous and kind.  I am very pleased with the final auction results.

Mary K.


Drove 3 hours today to pick up my purchases.   Scott met me.   Was friendly, knowledgeable and went beyond making us feel important.  Not just people  who made a purchase.  It is my first time dealing with this auction house.  I look forward to future auctions.

Monique F.


Very helpful. Great experience. Items came in close or over to what predicted. Would use any time. Jeff W. goes above and beyond to be helpful and offer advice or even introducing you to others who can help.

Michael R.


A GREAT EXPERIENCE! I’ve been wanting to bid and win at Garth’s for quite a while and I won my Auctions and everything was perfect …. HOPE to be a regular.

James B.


Amazing Auction House. This is my second time winning auctions from Garth’s. The process from beginning to the pick up of the items was smooth and very easy and the staff was great!!!!!

Ray D.


"Very professional in all aspects of the auction process.I have been dealing with Garth’s Auction house for many years. I have always been treated like I am the most important person. They have great items, great photography/descriptions. They are truly one of the best auction houses I have used from all over the world. Thanks!"

Ted K.


"Always professional and very helpful."

Kenneth D.


"Trusted Auction House.Great Auction House, one of THE BEST!!"

Lyssa S.


"Garth’s is top notch!Garths is a top rate auction house. They represent their items accurately. I am always more than pleased when I see my items in person."

Linda M.


"Garth's was ompletely great in responding to my questions about [item] I ended up purchasing. They couldn't have been nicer and provided all the information I needed."

Raymond F.


"Great auction house. Will get this auction house on my short list of preferences. Even better than expected."

Phil M.


"Couldn't have been easier from bid to ship. And their office people were the best! Shipping was simple, fast, and convenient and handled in-house.... just the way everyone should operate."

Daniel K.


"Excellently Curated Collections and Outstanding Customer Service. We have been customers of Garth's for at least twenty years and have purchased dozens of items. An excellent auction house the offers top-end items and excellent curation and presentation. Any questions or concerns that we have ever had were treated with the utmost respect and promptness."

Donald C.


"SMOOTH TRANSACTION. Great items, easy to deal with"

Sarah M.


"Great Service! Garth’s was very helpful and accommodating."



"You can trust Garth's. The people that work for Garth's are experienced, helpful and will give an honest condition report."



"Wonderful experienceI was so pleased from start to finish. Thank you so much!"



"I would like everybody to know that this auction house is very reliable and very helpful."



"Expect integrity! We have bought and sold with Garth’s for over 30 years. We have been treated well, and if a concern (seldom) arose we were properly addressed. We expect to continue a relationship with this business."



"One of the Great Midwestern Auction HousesI've been dealing with Garth's for years, and I hope to deal with the for years to come."



"Best auction house in the nation! Great staff!"



"Expeditious process and delivery. First class operation."



"Great Experience. Fantastic Shipping. Very Happy.

First time with Garth's Auction House, and it was a great experience. My lot was even better than described and so interesting. The shipping was incredible. It honestly took me about 4 hours (spaced over 2 evenings) to unwrap and examine all of the items included. The packing was incredible, I feel I certainly got my money's worth. Will happily purchase from them again in the future without hesitation. THANK YOU!"



"Professional in Every Regard.

I have been a client of Garth's for several decades and have always been impressed with their professionalism in every regard. Item descriptions are accurate and the staff are always helpful if additional information is requested. I live in Columbus where Garth's is located and have attended many item previews and auctions. Presentations of the items are done with great care and the venue (especially their new location at the old Columbus Power Plant) is comfortable and conducive to examining every item thoroughly. I have had a few difficulties with the on-line auction system (s) that Garth's has used during the pandemic, but I believe this is a function of the new medium and not due to Garth's. I look forward to the return to participating in person-which for me is a valued part of the experience."



I am OVER THE MOON with this purchase! I could not be happier with the item, the beautifully and carefully wrapped items, the fast shipping - the whole experience has been a pleasure. So glad I won this amazing treasure box. I will leave a review on Live Auctioneers when their system allows.
Thank you, Sally"



"I have won many items from Garth’s and have always been happy with my purchases. They are a top notch auction house from the products to the bidding to the check out process. I will use them again guaranteed!

Robin H."



"This was my first experience purchasing from your auction. The entire process was first rate from start to finish. I made a couple of calls to your company and the person that I spoke to was very nice and provided me with quick informative answers to my questions. The items I received were wonderful and exactly as described. The shipping cost was very reasonable and the difficult to ship items were expertly packed and arrived in great condition. Thank you for having such a great, professional company. I hope to deal with you many more times in the future.




"First time dealing with this auction house and I’m very pleased with my experience. Things were well represented with any flaws noted. Items arrived well packaged and in excellent shape. Shipping times were better than other auctions I’ve purchased from. Good experience."



"These guys are truly committed to great service!!Being new to auctions has been very exciting, but for me it is also a learning experience. Garth's took care of my questions and that made me feel more secure about my purchases. Great job Garth's!!!"



"Garth is the standard by which I judge other auctioneers. Consummately professional with a helpful and friendly staff. Plus, they always manage to find the most desirable things to offer."



"Simple and easy bidding. Great staff. Very knowledgeable, friendly and helpful. I will continue to patronize Garth's and look forward to their line up of quality antiques."



"Hello Jeff,

I just wanted to take a minute to say thank you to your staff for being so kind to me when I recently brought some collectibles to be auctioned by Garth’s.  Jeff Spear and everyone there was so nice to work with.  A few of my items went in the July auction and the majority of them were sold in August.  I had a chance to stop by the August auction for a couple of hours and was very pleased with what my items were being sold for.


At any rate, it was a pleasure working with Garth’s and I would like to bring more collectibles for a future auction.

Thank you, S.A."



"My wife and I recently traveled from northern Ohio to Garths to have some Bronze pieces appraised.  The group of folks we dealt with were without a doubt professional, informative and most of all so very kind and a pleasure to deal with.  From the moment I walked in the door and dealt with the lovely young lady at the reception area to the great gals and fella that took time to help me, I felt at ease with no rush or hurry.
Thanks to all of the great folks I dealt with.
Please stay safe and I'm sure I will return to do business with you all.
Regards and Cheers to all, Harry"



"You people are FANTASTIC! The shipment arrived last evening. As usual, extremely well packed and better than the description in the auction. Your group is on the top of my list of auctioneers. THANK YOU!"



"I know that Bill has already written to let you know that the pickup here went well, but I wanted to add my own note of appreciation and acclaim for the hard work JW put in here. he was so polite and considerate, listening as we tried to give background on the very eclectic collection of things we had acquired. It is difficult to part with objects that had given us a lot of pleasure over the years, but it was softened by knowing so much of it is "going home"....Only time will tell how the items go at auction, but at least they aren't being discarded or going to Goodwill to meet their fate. JW was fun to have around and is certainly an asset to your company, especially in one so young. Thanks again."



"The catalog arrived today, very impressive, thank you. Your staff is not only efficient but very polite in helping me stumble through using UPS for my requests. This speaks highly of you and your organization."



"I have been in the jewelry and diamond business for the past 46 years and I have done business with thousands of stores and dealers across the USA and Europe. It's such a pleasure dealing with all of you at Garth's. Everything went well and I look forward to doing lots more business with you in the very near future. I like you and I trust you and I would recommend you to buyers that appreciate good quality and want to be treated WELL."

Rob H.

"Its been a busy auction arrivals from Garth's Auctions. Sometimes bidding from auction photos can be disappointing. These [items which just arrived] are 500% better in person and I'm thrilled. Unbelivable professional packing also. Thanks Garth's, Andrew and Amelia!"

bottom of page